Is this really a content gap?
Help a camping shop decide what its tent guide should answer. Practice with fictional evidence, then compare the real bag-policy report.
A real searchprovidence park bag policy
Google already shows
Title Town PDX/guides/game-day-providence-park/
- 508 impressions
- 4 clicks
- 9.4 average position
Google Search Console, Title Town PDX; Sep 1 to Oct 28, 2026.House rule from the game: a slot with a piece in it is not a gap.
What would you recommend?
Read the reports, choose an action, then explain your reasoning. Use the analysis prompt and worked answer to check your thinking.
Fictional practice data. K means thousand. Not results from my sites or clients.
Difficulty
Beginner: Check what the existing answer is missing
A fictional camping shop has a tent-buying guide. A shopper wants to know whether two adults and their bags will fit. An AI tool recommends another article.
Read the shopper’s question and the existing guide. What does the guide still fail to answer?
Check the source evidence
| Search | Impressions | Clicks | Page shown |
|---|---|---|---|
| tent size for two adults | 1K | 100 | Existing tent-buying guide |
| Guide section | What it says |
|---|---|
| Capacity labels | A two-person label describes sleeping capacity. It does not promise room for bags. |
| Buying advice | Check the dimensions of the particular model you are considering. |
Analyze the reports
Download the reports and attach them to your AI tool. Paste the analysis prompt, then check its answer against the evidence.
Read or select the prompt
Then check its work. Check the reporting periods, one important source row and any calculation. Does its recommendation actually follow from that evidence?
Help checking the analysis
- Download the complete case and give it to an AI tool with the analysis prompt.
- Ask AI to organize the evidence. Check the dates, one important row and any calculation it uses.
- Choose or reject its recommendation. Explain the page action you would take and what you would check next.
If you’re stuck: Compare the shopper’s decision with the sentences in the guide. Which part is still unanswered?
Explain your decision
Use the evidence to explain your choice and next check. Your writing is not submitted or graded.
Describe the people and gear involved.
Point to a sentence in the extract.
Name evidence you would collect before promising that a tent fits.
Compare with a worked answer
Does not fit this case: Commission a separate tent-size article using the same capacity explanation.
The supplied explanation already covers the label. Another page with that explanation would not resolve where the people and bags go.
Fits this case: Check usable dimensions and illustrate the people-and-bags layout in the guide.
The extract tells readers to check dimensions but does not help them do it. A supported layout could answer the unresolved fit decision; it does not require a separate page yet.
Partly right: Ask shoppers whether they generally prefer larger tents before inspecting a model.
Interviews may reveal preferences, but this shopper already has a concrete fit question. You still need model-specific dimensions or a layout to answer it.
How I would approach it
I would collect a specific model’s dimensions and draft a labeled layout in the existing guide. Until those facts are available, I would avoid saying which size fits.
What we still don’t know
We do not know the tent’s shape, the people’s gear or whether a simple floor plan represents usable space accurately.
Check your own explanation
- Names the people-and-bags decision.
- Uses the guide extract rather than the impression count as evidence of missing information.
- Requests model-specific evidence without promising a new page or fit result.
Keep your work
Choose an answer and write your reasoning. Compare with the worked answer.
Notes are not saved automatically. Download your notes before leaving.
Intermediate: Turn evidence into a useful page addition
The same fictional shop has one afternoon to improve the guide. The team has checked one display tent and measured the pads and bags shown below. The dimensions are fictional exercise inputs, not buying advice.
Use the measurements to sketch a possible layout. Decide what to add to the guide and what your example cannot prove.
Check the source evidence
| Item | Dimensions | Count |
|---|---|---|
| Tent floor | 220 cm long × 140 cm wide | 1 |
| Sleeping pad | 190 cm long × 60 cm wide | 2 |
| Bag footprint | 40 cm wide × 30 cm deep | 2 |
| Source | Observation |
|---|---|
| Selected queries over 28 days | 5K impressions for questions about two adults plus bags. |
| Support inbox | 10 messages ask where bags go when both sleeping pads are inside. |
| Current guide | Explains capacity labels but contains no layout example. |
Analyze the reports
Download the reports and attach them to your AI tool. Paste the analysis prompt, then check its answer against the evidence.
Read or select the prompt
Then check its work. Check the reporting periods, one important source row and any calculation. Does its recommendation actually follow from that evidence?
Help checking the analysis
- Download the complete case and give it to an AI tool with the analysis prompt.
- Ask AI to organize the evidence. Check the dates, one important row and any calculation it uses.
- Choose or reject its recommendation. Explain the page action you would take and what you would check next.
If you’re stuck: Two pads side by side use 120 cm of the 140 cm width. What remains along the length? Can both bags fit across it?
Explain your decision
Use the evidence to explain your choice and next check. Your writing is not submitted or graded.
Describe or sketch their positions and label the dimensions used.
Explain why one rectangular example cannot establish fit for every tent.
Give them one task that checks whether the example is understandable.
Name something you could observe in the reader task or a model check.
Compare with a worked answer
Does not fit this case: Replace the capacity paragraph with a table saying every two-person tent holds two adults and bags.
The packet covers one simplified rectangle and a specific set of gear. It cannot establish what every two-person model holds.
Partly right: Create a new model page with the dimensions, then link it from the guide without testing the layout.
A model page may be useful if it serves a distinct comparison task. But publishing the dimensions alone still leaves the supplied people-and-bags question unresolved.
Fits this case: Add the dimensioned two-pad, two-bag layout as a limited example, then test readers’ understanding.
Two pads occupy 120 cm of width and 190 cm of length, leaving a 30 cm end strip in the 220 cm-long floor. Two 40 cm-wide bags fit side by side across that strip in this simplified model. The example can explain this arrangement without claiming universal comfort.
How I would approach it
I would draw the supplied layout and label every dimension, then ask a reader to place the pads and bags without help. I would state that sloping walls, doors and real usable space still need checking before treating it as practical product advice.
What we still don’t know
The geometric example leaves out wall slopes, internal obstructions and comfort. Query interest and support messages do not validate the drawing’s usability.
Another approach worth considering
A short overhead demonstration could work better than a static diagram if readers struggle to interpret the layout. It must use checked measurements and the same limits.
What would change my mind
If readers misplace the bags, or checking the display tent invalidates the rectangular floor model, I would revise the example before publication.
Check your own explanation
- Shows two pads using 120 cm of width and 190 cm of length.
- Places both bags in the 30 cm end strip without inventing more space.
- Labels the example as one simplified model, not a universal capacity rule.
- Defines a reader task and a sign that the explanation needs revision.
Keep your work
Choose an answer and write your reasoning. Compare with the worked answer.
Notes are not saved automatically. Download your notes before leaving.
Advanced practice: Choose an original contribution within a real constraint
A fictional camping retailer can spend 16 staff-hours on one prototype. Its goal is to help shoppers decide whether a tent fits two adults and their bags. Broad tent-size guides already exist. You must choose a useful contribution and a small test, not promise a ranking result.
Group the CSV searches by what shoppers want to do. Add up each group’s impressions and choose one useful improvement that fits the available time.
Check the source evidence
| Evidence source | What is available |
|---|---|
| Current tent-buying guide | Defines capacity labels and waterproof-rating terms. Says to check model dimensions. Has no measured layout comparison. |
| Recent support notes | 9 conversations ask about adults plus bags; 2 ask about pitching a tent alone. Notes are a convenience sample. |
| Display stock | Four display tents, two pad sizes and two bag sizes can be measured in-store. |
| Staff plan | 16 staff-hours available this week. A labeled four-tent layout pilot and two reader sessions are estimated to use 16 hours. |
| Product feed | No maintained manufacturer-dimension feed exists. Building and checking a product-wide filter is estimated at 40 hours. |
| File | Contents |
|---|---|
| Query CSV | 24 queries, impressions, the page shown and the recorded period. Total impressions: 20K. |
Download the raw fictional query packet (CSV)Have AI propose groups. Check ambiguous searches and totals against the source rows.
Analyze the reports
Download the reports and attach them to your AI tool. Paste the analysis prompt, then check its answer against the evidence.
Read or select the prompt
Then check its work. Check the source periods, a decisive row and any calculation. Challenge its strongest assumption and ask what would reverse the recommendation.
Help checking the analysis
- Download the complete case and give it to an AI tool with the analysis prompt.
- Ask AI to organize the evidence. Check the dates, one important row and any calculation it uses.
- Choose or reject its recommendation. Explain the page action you would take and what you would check next.
If you’re stuck: First separate the queries by what someone is trying to decide. Then compare the prototype’s evidence needs, hours and maintenance burden with the packet.
Explain your decision
Use the evidence to explain your choice and next check. Your writing is not submitted or graded.
Show which searches belong together; explain ambiguous wording and check the overall total.
Use the shopper goal, existing coverage and support notes as well as search counts.
Name what you would measure, the method, time needed and limits.
Describe a task, what successful understanding looks like and what would make you revise or stop.
Compare with a worked answer
Partly right: Group the solo-setup queries at 5K impressions; prototype a consistent setup demonstration to help shoppers pitch a tent alone.
The setup queries do total 5K impressions in this selected packet, and there is some support evidence for that task. It addresses a different decision from the stated people-and-bags brief, however, and the packet supplies no checked 16-hour setup estimate. Validate priority and feasibility before changing the brief.
Fits this case: Pilot four measured layouts for the 10K fit-and-space impressions, then test two shoppers within the 16-hour estimate.
The first eight fit-and-space query rows total 10K impressions; the two other task groups total 5K each. Query counts alone do not choose the project, but this group also matches the 9 support conversations, the missing layout evidence and the checked 16-hour prototype estimate. The shopper sessions test comprehension rather than rankings.
Does not fit this case: Group the waterproof questions at 10K impressions; build a new waterproof guide from the current rating definitions.
Those query rows total 5K, not 10K. The current guide already defines the terms, and a new version of those definitions does not address the stated people-and-bags task. Further research might reveal a distinct waterproofing decision, but this proposal has not established it.
How I would approach it
I would classify the eight fit-and-space searches together and sum their 10K impressions. The solo-setup and waterproof-related groups each sum to 5K. I would check ambiguous wording against the actual task rather than assuming a keyword cluster is automatically a page. Fit is my initial priority because its group aligns with 9 support notes, missing layout evidence and a checked 16-hour pilot. My method would name the gear, usable dimensions, placement rules and limitations. I would ask each shopper to choose a layout for a supplied gear set and explain the choice; failed tasks would change the prototype before expansion.
What we still don’t know
The support sample may be biased. Four display models do not represent all tents. A small comprehension test cannot prove demand, sales impact or a lasting competitive advantage.
Another approach worth considering
A smaller filter or a setup demonstration could be worth testing under a different brief. It would need its own evidence, feasible estimate and identified reader task; neither should be called original research without performing and documenting the work.
What would change my mind
If grouping shows a different dominant task, staff cannot measure consistently, or shoppers still cannot compare the layouts, I would change the scope or stop.
Check your own explanation
- Groups the 24 raw queries into defensible tasks, accounts for the 20K total and identifies 10K fit/space, 5K setup and 5K waterproof-related impressions; explains any ambiguous grouping.
- Distinguishes existing definitions from missing model-specific evidence.
- Chooses a prototype consistent with 16 hours and the stated shopper task.
- Specifies a repeatable method and its limits.
- Defines observable reader-test success/failure without claiming rankings or a permanent moat.
Keep your work
Choose an answer and write your reasoning. Compare with the worked answer.
Notes are not saved automatically. Download your notes before leaving.
Something wrong, or a different approach? Include your evidence and lesson link. Leave out private information.
Optional: explore a worked real report
Use this as a reference when checking your analysis. You do not need to complete a second set of notes.
Check 1: what does Google already show?
You run content for two small sites with time for one new page this month. Imagine an AI tool has listed three "missing pages". Before writing anything, check which page Google already shows for each search, and decide what each one deserves. There are four searches because two Cascade searches belong to the same proposed page.
Title Town PDX covers Portland's women's pro teams. The Quack Report covers Oregon Ducks football. The tool's list is below, with what Google Search Console recorded for each search from September 1 to October 28, 2026. Impressions are how often a page appeared in Google's results; average position is its average place in the results (lower is better).
| Site | Search | Page Google showed | Impressions | Clicks | Avg. position |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Title Town PDX | providence park bag policy | /guides/game-day-providence-park/ | 508 | 4 | 9.4 |
| Title Town PDX | portland cascade softball | /cascade/roster/ | 377 | 2 | 7.5 |
| Title Town PDX | portland cascade | /cascade/roster/ | 289 | 0 | 7.8 |
| The Quack Report | our beloved ducks forum | /community/ | 1.5K | 0 | 6.0 |
See why each answer is right or wrong
Not quiteAll three are gaps: the site has no page for any of them.The export records an existing URL for every search in this list. That does not establish that the page answers it. Inspect what the page offers before deciding whether a new page is needed. The trap is treating a suggested topic as proof an answer page is missing.
CorrectThe report lists a page for each search, so the question is whether that page answers it.That's the test before any new page: which pages appeared for the search, and whether they answer it. It turns three "write a page" tasks into three different decisions.
Not quiteWrite a page for the forum search first; it has the most impressions.Volume alone doesn't say the search belongs to you. Look at what people want before ranking by size. The trap is chasing the biggest number in the list.
Read the video explanation
Check the page before adding another.
The guide already has a bag-policy FAQ.
Check the venue’s current policy.
Check 2: the bag policy search
"providence park bag policy" got 508 impressions and 4 clicks, almost all on Title Town PDX's game-day guide, at an average position of 9.4. The guide already has a bag-policy FAQ. Finding a matching URL is only the first check: read its answer and follow the original policy source before deciding whether anything needs to change.
See why each answer is right or wrong
CorrectCheck the FAQ against the current stadium policy and see whether readers can find it. Keep or improve the guide based on that check.The question is already covered, so this is not evidence of a missing answer. Verify that the existing FAQ is accurate and easy to find. Keeping it is valid if it does the job; a targeted update is valid if your inspection finds a specific problem.
CorrectConsider a separate page, but first establish what distinct need it would serve beyond this FAQ.A separate page is worth considering if you first establish a distinct reader task. These rows do not establish that need, so this is an investigation to justify before publishing. Compare what a new page would add with what the existing FAQ already answers.
Not quiteIgnore the question because four clicks is not worth checking.A low click count does not explain why people did not click or whether the answer is useful. Keeping the guide after checking its answer is different from dismissing the reader's question because a count is small.
Check 3: the team page that already exists
"portland cascade softball" and "portland cascade" got 377 and 289 impressions. The site has a main page for the Portland Cascade, but Google showed the roster page most of the time (92% and 85% of impressions), at positions 7.5 and 7.8.
See why each answer is right or wrong
Not quiteWrite the new page the tool suggests.A main team page already exists. Inspect whether it serves the same need before adding another. If two pages would do the same job, improving or combining the existing pages may be simpler.
CorrectInspect current results and both existing pages, then update the main page if its opening misses the relevant question.The report identifies which URL appeared, not which format people wanted. Compare both existing pages and current results. Keep separate pages when they serve distinct needs, and change a specific mismatch you find.
Partly rightMerge the roster into the main page so there's one page.Combining pages may help if they answer the same need. The rows alone do not establish that, so read them and check their different jobs before removing one.
Check 4: the biggest number on the list
"our beloved ducks forum" got 1.5K impressions and 0 clicks on The Quack Report's community directory, at an average position of 6.0. Our Beloved Ducks is a fan forum on another site; the directory lists it, with a link, among other Ducks communities.
See why each answer is right or wrong
Not quiteWrite an "Our Beloved Ducks forum" page to capture the traffic.This search names an external forum. A new page would need to help visitors in a way the existing directory does not. The impression count alone does not justify adding a page to capture the traffic.
CorrectNothing new: keep the directory's entry clear and linked, so anyone who lands there finds the forum.The directory already identifies the forum and links to it. Keep that route clear and use the limited publishing time on a question the site can usefully answer. These impressions and zero clicks do not reveal which other results appeared or why anyone did not click.
Not quiteStart a Quack Report forum to compete.Starting a community would require a separate case for why readers need it and why this site should run it. These impressions do not establish that need. First check whether the existing directory helps people reach the forum they searched for.
Your real-report answer review
- Right
- 0
- Partly right
- 0
- Wrong
- 0
- Unanswered
- 0
Use the explanations beside each question to review your choices, then write your recommendation.
Only your latest choice for each real-report question counts. Your written recommendation is not graded.
Review each answer
Write your recommendation
Write what you would do, the evidence behind it and what you would check next. Your notes stay on this page until you download them; they are not submitted or saved automatically.
Compare with a worked recommendation
I would inspect the existing bag-policy FAQ and its official source before creating another page. If it is accurate and easy to find, I would keep it; if not, I would name the specific update it needs. For Cascade, I would compare the existing team and roster pages with current search results, then change a specific mismatch rather than assume another page is needed. The community directory already links to the external forum, so I would keep that route clear instead of funding a new page from its impression count. I would leave the new-page slot unused unless inspection established a distinct unmet need.
Compare the evidence and next check with your own. If you would choose a different action, explain what supports it.
Ready to build a whole page? Explore the Moat Map course (Free during early access).