Why isn’t my page showing up?

Choose where to spend your time before trying to get every page into Google.

Try the first question

A site owner wants every page indexed. Would you agree?

You have one session to investigate whether CheckMyTap needs indexing work. Compare its report with three other real reports from my own sites, then recommend what to inspect before anyone starts rewriting, deleting pages or requesting indexing. This assignment sets the priority; the counts do not tell you which site matters most.

Indexed means Google has put a page in its search index, making it eligible to appear in results. It does not guarantee a good position or clicks. “Not indexed” includes several different situations, some intentional.

Pages Google knows about, October 22, 2026. Each site has a different size and purpose.
SiteIndexedNot indexed
RatingPlate453
CheckMyTap1912K
UpOrbit76267
The Quack Report14622
Download these rows (CSV)
What can you decide from these totals alone?

RatingPlate: a small bucket with a specific explanation

RatingPlate’s export lists 45 indexed pages and 3 unindexed pages. All the unindexed pages are reported as “Page with redirect”: their URLs send visitors elsewhere. The export does not name the URLs or their destinations.

What would you recommend for these redirect rows?

This is a check to make, not a claim that the redirects are correct. The summary export cannot establish that. For the separate question of whether an indexed page reaches searchers, use the search performance report.

CheckMyTap: the same label hides several decisions

CheckMyTap helps people look up water-quality information. Its report contains 2K unindexed pages. Read the breakdown before deciding what that number means.

Why CheckMyTap pages were not indexed, October 22, 2026. These are report categories, not verdicts about page quality.
Reported reasonPages
Not found (404)228
Excluded by ‘noindex’ tag148
Blocked by robots.txt6
Page with redirect6
Discovered - currently not indexed1.1K
Crawled - currently not indexed521
Duplicate, Google chose different canonical than user1
Download these rows (CSV)

“Discovered” means Google knows about a URL but has not crawled it yet. “Crawled” means Google fetched the page; this group has not been added to the index.

Which investigation would give you a useful next decision?
Understand the labels and choose a next action

An important page is blocked by mistake. If its live page has an unintended noindex instruction or crawl restriction, correct that setting, test the page again and check its status later. Keep an intentional restriction when the page should remain out of search.

An old URL redirects. If it sends people to the intended replacement, keep the redirect and inspect the replacement. If it sends them somewhere unrelated, correct the destination.

Google knows a useful page but has not crawled it. Check whether relevant pages link to it and whether it belongs in the sitemap. Add missing routes where appropriate, then monitor crawling. A link or sitemap entry does not guarantee indexing.

Google crawled a page but left it out. Inspect the recorded and live page, the preferred URL and what the content answers. Fix an identified technical problem; improve a missing answer; consider combining overlapping pages only after confirming they serve the same need. The report label alone does not choose among those actions.

A 404 means the page was not found. A noindex instruction asks search engines not to index a page. Robots.txt can restrict crawling. A canonical is a preferred version of a page; Google may choose a different version. Each can reflect an intentional choice or an accident, so inspect examples rather than treating the label as the diagnosis.

Review the change: did a smaller count mean improvement?

CheckMyTap: the not-indexed count fell, but so did the indexed count.
Report dateIndexedNot indexedKnown total
2026-09-202522.3K2.5K
2026-10-221912K2.2K
Download these rows (CSV)
What would you tell the owner about this change?
20-second walkthrough. Two dated Page indexing chart snapshots; a drawn comparison, not an account recording.
Read the video explanation

The not-indexed count fell.

The indexed count fell too.

Which pages changed?

Now apply the distinction to your own site. Start with a page someone needs, not a target percentage. Find its status in URL Inspection, compare Google’s recorded version with the live page where necessary, and decide whether its current treatment is intentional. A successful live test does not guarantee indexing.

These snapshots show movements in the reports, not what caused them. For a related example after a rebuild, check the missing page before treating the whole site.

Write your recommendation

For your assigned CheckMyTap investigation, write the short recommendation you would send to the site owner: what you would inspect, what you would leave alone for now, and which finding would change your action. Your notes stay on this page until you download them; they are not submitted or saved automatically.

Compare with a worked recommendation

For this assigned CheckMyTap session, I would inspect pages the owner wants people to find before recommending deletion or bulk indexing requests. Its October 22, 2026 report shows 2K unindexed pages across different reasons. I would correct an unintended block on an important page, but keep an intended exclusion. For discovered pages, I would check links and crawl access; for crawled pages, I would inspect the preferred URL and the answer before proposing an update or combination. RatingPlate’s 3 redirect rows illustrate why the same fix should not apply everywhere. CheckMyTap’s smaller unindexed total is not proof of improvement because its indexed count fell too. I would track whether the important pages reach the people who need them, rather than treat a smaller excluded count as the goal.

Compare the evidence and next check with your own. If you would choose a different action, explain what supports it.

Read how to find where an individual page stopped

Use arrow keys to move. Enter opens. Esc closes.

Ask Bella

Ask Bella Hayden's corgi, who answers from this site and cites every fact.

BELLA

WOOF. I'm Bella, Hayden's corgi. He's my human. Ask me about him; every answer cites its source.

Reading this page? The top button is my short version of it.

How it works: the answers are written ahead from this site's pages, and anything else gets a search of the site that shows you its exact words. Every claim has a numbered source you can tap. Nothing is generated while you wait, nothing is made up, and nothing you type leaves your browser. Every answer, in plain HTML

Top

This page was last updated