Did my traffic really drop?

The Quack Report has fewer clicks from Google. Check the reporting periods before recommending a rewrite.

Try one decision

One full month. One month still in progress.

September 1–30, 2026

444 Google clicks

October 1–23, 2026

182 Google clicks

Google Search Console, The Quack Report; Sep 1 to Oct 23, 2026.Check the reporting periods before explaining the change.

Check 1: what would you tell the site owner?

The Quack Report covers Oregon Ducks football. Would you assign a rewrite based on this report?

Google clicks in the report
PeriodClicks
September 1 to 30, 2026444
October 1 to 23, 2026182

Source: The Quack Report’s archived Search Console export, through 2026-10-23.

Before you open anything else, what's wrong with comparing those two totals?
Compare the same dates

September 1 to 23375

October 1 to 23182

Both periods cover the first 23 days. October is still lower; the totals alone don't explain why.

Watch the dates change

Notice which total changes when the periods match.

10-second silent walkthrough, drawn from the archived export. This is not a recording of the Search Console interface.

Read the video explanation

Compare the same dates.

Match September to October’s 23 days.

The cause still needs investigation.

Practice with another traffic report

What would you recommend?

Choose which periods to compare. Then explain your choice in the full exercise below.

Fictional practice data. K means thousand. Not results from my sites or clients.

Beginner: Choose a fair comparison

A fictional bicycle website recorded fewer Google search clicks in May so far. A click means someone selected a search result; it is not the same measure as an analytics session.

Before deciding whether to rewrite anything, choose two periods you can fairly compare.

Evidence for your decision

Fictional report. May is still in progress.
PeriodDays coveredGoogle clicks
April301K
May so far15600
Which comparison uses recorded clicks from the same number of days?

Continue: explain your choice

Analyze the reports

Download the reports and attach them to your AI tool. Paste the analysis prompt, then check its answer against the evidence.

Download the case and reports

Read or select the prompt

Then check its work. Check the reporting periods, one important source row and any calculation. Does its recommendation actually follow from that evidence?

Help checking the analysis

  1. Download the complete case and give it to an AI tool with the analysis prompt.
  2. Ask AI to organize the evidence. Check the dates, one important row and any calculation it uses.
  3. Choose or reject its recommendation. Explain the page action you would take and what you would check next.

If you’re stuck: Which option uses recorded results covering 15 days in both months?

Explain your decision

Use the evidence to explain your choice and next check. Your writing is not submitted or graded.

Name the start and end dates for both periods.

Explain what makes the periods more comparable.

Separate a change in clicks from its cause.

Keep your work

Choose an answer and write your reasoning. Compare with the worked answer.

Notes are not saved automatically. Download your notes before leaving.

Intermediate: Separate the loss from the explanation

A fictional bicycle site has two complete 28-day reports. Commuting and repairs are separate page groups. The total combines them; it is not another group.

Find which page group lost clicks. Use impressions and average position to decide what to check next.

Check the source evidence
Fictional Google Search Console reports for equal 28-day periods. Average position is averaged across recorded appearances, not a fixed ranking.
Page groupPeriodImpressionsClicksAverage position
Commuting guidesEarlier 28 days20K2K5
Commuting guidesLater 28 days10K1K5
Repair guidesEarlier 28 days10K1K5
Repair guidesLater 28 days10K1K5
Total, not an additional groupEarlier 28 days30K3KNot combined here
Total, not an additional groupLater 28 days20K2KNot combined here
Which finding best supports the next investigation?

Analyze the reports

Download the reports and attach them to your AI tool. Paste the analysis prompt, then check its answer against the evidence.

Download the case and reports

Read or select the prompt

Then check its work. Check the reporting periods, one important source row and any calculation. Does its recommendation actually follow from that evidence?

Help checking the analysis

  1. Download the complete case and give it to an AI tool with the analysis prompt.
  2. Ask AI to organize the evidence. Check the dates, one important row and any calculation it uses.
  3. Choose or reject its recommendation. Explain the page action you would take and what you would check next.

If you’re stuck: Compare both measures inside each group. Does the click loss happen without an impression change?

Explain your decision

Use the evidence to explain your choice and next check. Your writing is not submitted or graded.

Use the two groups and their counts to explain the total change.

Compare impressions and average position without claiming a cause.

Name the breakdown and what you would compare.

Keep your work

Choose an answer and write your reasoning. Compare with the worked answer.

Notes are not saved automatically. Download your notes before leaving.

Advanced practice: Prioritize a repair using separate data sources

A fictional cycling publisher has four developer hours today. The agreed goal is to protect the email-sign-up journey before a newsletter campaign tomorrow. Tracking and consent settings are unchanged. A separate editor has already corrected a bridge-closure warning.

Choose which problem to fix first with four developer hours. Use the search and analytics reports, without treating clicks and sessions as the same thing.

Check the source evidence
Fictional complete 28-day periods. “Sign-ups” counts distinct analytics landing sessions containing at least one successful sign-up event, once per session. The session filter and attribution are identical; GSC clicks remain separate.
Landing pagePeriodGSC clicksGoogle landing sessionsEmail sign-ups
CommutingApril 1–28, 20262K1.8K100
CommutingMay 1–28, 20261K900100
RepairsApril 1–28, 20261K80050
RepairsMay 1–28, 20261K80050
Bike reviewsApril 1–28, 20265001K100
Bike reviewsMay 1–28, 20265001K20

Download the fictional source comparison (CSV)Six dated page/period rows. Calculate the sign-up rate within analytics; do not divide analytics events by GSC clicks.

Fictional checks performed today, with effort estimates.
Check or proposalObserved evidenceEstimated effort
Bike-review sign-up button on phoneThe button points to an old sign-up route that returns 404 in three repeated checks. The desktop button reaches the current form.Repair and phone/desktop verification: 2 hours
Commuting traffic investigationThe matched-period query breakdown has not been inspected. No live access problem found in the sampled pages.Investigation: 4 hours
New bike-review comparison contentAn editor suggested it; no current evidence shows it would repair the sign-up journey.Prototype: 2 hours
Given today’s goal and four-hour limit, which first allocation is best supported?

Analyze the reports

Download the reports and attach them to your AI tool. Paste the analysis prompt, then check its answer against the evidence.

Download the case and reports

Read or select the prompt

Then check its work. Check the source periods, a decisive row and any calculation. Challenge its strongest assumption and ask what would reverse the recommendation.

Help checking the analysis

  1. Download the complete case and give it to an AI tool with the analysis prompt.
  2. Ask AI to organize the evidence. Check the dates, one important row and any calculation it uses.
  3. Choose or reject its recommendation. Explain the page action you would take and what you would check next.

If you’re stuck: Use the analytics session denominator for the sign-up calculation. Then compare the result with the stated campaign goal, observed fault and effort limit.

Explain your decision

Use the evidence to explain your choice and next check. Your writing is not submitted or graded.

Show the analytics counts and calculation for both periods.

Connect the observed problem to the campaign goal and available hours.

Explain which other work can wait under this goal.

Include the page on phone and desktop and whether sign-ups are recorded.

Name a concrete check result, and avoid claiming the fault explains every lost sign-up.

Keep your work

Choose an answer and write your reasoning. Compare with the worked answer.

Notes are not saved automatically. Download your notes before leaving.

Something wrong, or a different approach? Include your evidence and lesson link. Leave out private information.

Optional: explore a worked real report

Use this as a reference when checking your analysis. You do not need to complete a second set of notes.

Checks 2 and 3: a total hides the days inside it

Look for unusually large days and check the dates before explaining the change. A daily pattern can suggest where to investigate; it cannot tell you the cause by itself.

Daily Google clicks, September 1 to October 23, 2026September 5 is the largest day, with 187 clicks. The full daily figures and game context are available in the table below.18702026-09-01: 10 clicks2026-09-02: 8 clicks2026-09-03: 12 clicks2026-09-04: 12 clicks2026-09-05: 187 clicks; Boise State2026-09-06: 31 clicks2026-09-07: 17 clicks2026-09-08: 6 clicks2026-09-09: 5 clicks2026-09-10: 5 clicks2026-09-11: 4 clicks2026-09-12: 15 clicks; Oklahoma State2026-09-13: 11 clicks2026-09-14: 5 clicks2026-09-15: 5 clicks2026-09-16: 2 clicks2026-09-17: 4 clicks2026-09-18: 10 clicks; Portland State2026-09-19: 4 clicks2026-09-20: 3 clicks2026-09-21: 8 clicks2026-09-22: 4 clicks2026-09-23: 7 clicks2026-09-24: 5 clicks2026-09-25: 2 clicks2026-09-26: 28 clicks; USC2026-09-27: 15 clicks2026-09-28: 11 clicks2026-09-29: 5 clicks2026-09-30: 3 clicks2026-10-01: 8 clicks2026-10-02: 9 clicks2026-10-03: 8 clicks; bye week2026-10-04: 7 clicks2026-10-05: 9 clicks2026-10-06: 4 clicks2026-10-07: 7 clicks2026-10-08: 7 clicks2026-10-09: 5 clicks2026-10-10: 36 clicks; UCLA2026-10-11: 12 clicks2026-10-12: 8 clicks2026-10-13: 4 clicks2026-10-14: 9 clicks2026-10-15: 14 clicks2026-10-16: 4 clicks2026-10-17: 7 clicks; Nebraska2026-10-18: 2 clicks2026-10-19: 3 clicks2026-10-20: 2 clicks2026-10-21: 4 clicks2026-10-22: 7 clicks2026-10-23: 6 clicksSep 1Oct 1Oct 23
Recorded Google clicks per day. Highlight: 2026-09-05, Boise State game day.
Inspect or download the daily data
Download daily Search Console data (CSV)
The Quack Report, 2026-09-01 to 2026-10-23
DateClicksContext
2026-09-0110No game listed
2026-09-028No game listed
2026-09-0312No game listed
2026-09-0412No game listed
2026-09-05187Boise State
2026-09-0631No game listed
2026-09-0717No game listed
2026-09-086No game listed
2026-09-095No game listed
2026-09-105No game listed
2026-09-114No game listed
2026-09-1215Oklahoma State
2026-09-1311No game listed
2026-09-145No game listed
2026-09-155No game listed
2026-09-162No game listed
2026-09-174No game listed
2026-09-1810Portland State
2026-09-194No game listed
2026-09-203No game listed
2026-09-218No game listed
2026-09-224No game listed
2026-09-237No game listed
2026-09-245No game listed
2026-09-252No game listed
2026-09-2628USC
2026-09-2715No game listed
2026-09-2811No game listed
2026-09-295No game listed
2026-09-303No game listed
2026-10-018No game listed
2026-10-029No game listed
2026-10-038bye week
2026-10-047No game listed
2026-10-059No game listed
2026-10-064No game listed
2026-10-077No game listed
2026-10-087No game listed
2026-10-095No game listed
2026-10-1036UCLA
2026-10-1112No game listed
2026-10-128No game listed
2026-10-134No game listed
2026-10-149No game listed
2026-10-1514No game listed
2026-10-164No game listed
2026-10-177Nebraska
2026-10-182No game listed
2026-10-193No game listed
2026-10-202No game listed
2026-10-214No game listed
2026-10-227No game listed
2026-10-236No game listed
The site covers football. Most listed games were on Saturdays, but September 18 was a Friday game and October 3 was a bye week, when the team didn't play. What would you compare next?
Clicks per day, grouped by the kind of day. The September opener and the following day are excluded. 2026-09-01 to 2026-10-23.
Days includedSeptemberOctober
Game days17.7 a day
over 3 days
21.5 a day
over 2 days
Monday to Thursday6.8 a day
over 18 days
6.6 a day
over 13 days
Other Fridays to Sundays7.3 a day
over 7 days
6.6 a day
over 8 days
See the worked decision and day groups

How the days are grouped

Game days are the days the team played. Other Fridays to Sundays are weekend days without a game; Monday to Thursday are ordinary weekdays. The opener on September 5 and the following day are kept apart so the largest part of the report does not dominate this comparison. That choice does not establish why either day had those clicks. September 18, a Friday game, counts as a game day; October 3, the bye week, counts as an ordinary weekend day.

Investigate before assigning a rewrite

October’s recorded clicks are lower, but the two totals cover different periods. September also contains a large day: 187 clicks on 2026-09-05, or 42% of its total. Taking that day out drops September from 444 clicks to 257, which shows how much one day moves the total (a different cut from the matched-dates comparison in check 1). But October has big days too, so rather than deleting days, the fairer test is to compare game days with game days and ordinary days with ordinary days.

Compare relevant dates and inspect the pages and queries behind the change. A schedule can help choose comparisons. It does not establish whether a matchup, search demand, a ranking change or something else caused the difference.

Check 4: now look at one page

Now look at the roster page. Impressions count appearances in Google’s results; they are not clicks. Write your first explanation before opening the worked answer.

The owner also asks about one page. On the October 10 game day, the roster page got more impressions than any other page on the site; it lists the team's players and its depth chart, the order of starters at each position. Searches containing “depth chart” gave it 1.3K impressions on October 10 and 94 on October 17. What would you look at before recommending a rewrite?

Exported searches containing “depth chart” for the roster page. Lower average position is better. These rows do not cover every search.
DateImpressionsClicksAverage position
2026-10-10133099.2
2026-10-179418.7
Inspect the query rows behind these totals

“Qb” means quarterback. Average position is the page’s result position averaged over its appearances for these exported searches; 1 is the top result. Search Console leaves out rare queries, so a missing row does not establish zero searches.

Selected exported rows for October 10 and 17, 2026. A missing query row does not establish zero searches.
Date and queryImpressionsClicks
2026-10-10
oregon qb depth chart
3950
2026-10-10
oregon football depth chart
2622
2026-10-10
oregon depth chart
2540
2026-10-10
oregon ducks depth chart
1051
2026-10-10
oregon ducks depth chart 2026
661
2026-10-10
oregon football depth chart 2026
592
2026-10-10
oregon depth chart 2026
530
2026-10-10
oregon qb depth chart 2026
491
2026-10-10
oregon ducks football depth chart 2026
252
2026-10-10
oregon ducks qb depth chart 2026
160
2026-10-10
oregon football qb depth chart
120
2026-10-10
oregon football roster 2026 depth chart
80
2026-10-10
ducks qb depth chart
70
2026-10-10
orgeon depth chart
40
2026-10-10
oregon ducks football roster 2026 depth chart
30
2026-10-10
oregon 2026 depth chart
20
2026-10-10
orgeon football depth chart
20
2026-10-10
2026 oregon football depth chart
10
2026-10-10
oregan football depth chart
10
2026-10-10
oregon depth chart football
10
2026-10-10
oregon ducks 2026 depth chart
10
2026-10-10
oregon ducks 2026 football depth chart
10
2026-10-10
oregon ducks football qb depth chart
10
2026-10-10
oregon fb depth chart
10
2026-10-10
oregon quarterback depth chart
10
2026-10-17
oregon qb depth chart 2026
420
2026-10-17
oregon ducks qb depth chart 2026
301
2026-10-17
oregon ducks football depth chart 2026
50
2026-10-17
oregon football depth chart 2026
40
2026-10-17
oregon depth chart 2026
30
2026-10-17
oregon football depth chart
20
2026-10-17
oregon ducks depth chart
10
2026-10-17
oregon ducks depth chart 2025
10
2026-10-17
oregon ducks depth chart 2026
10
2026-10-17
oregon ducks football 2026 depth chart
10
2026-10-17
oregon ducks football depth chart
10
2026-10-17
oregon ducks football roster 2026 depth chart
10
2026-10-17
oregon football qb depth chart
10
2026-10-17
oregon football roster 2026 depth chart
10
What would you do next before recommending a rewrite?

Download the selected query rows (CSV)
The same October 10 and 17 rows shown above. These are selected exported queries; a missing row does not mean zero searches.

Download the top pages on each game day (CSV)

Your real-report answer review

Use the explanations beside each question to review your choices, then write your recommendation.

Only your latest choice for each real-report question counts. Your written recommendation is not graded.

Write what you would do next

Write the recommendation

Keep it brief enough to send to a site owner. Your notes stay in this page until you download them; they are not submitted or saved automatically. Use only information you can share publicly.

Compare with a worked recommendation

Recorded clicks are lower in the October window, including when the same calendar dates are compared. September contains a large spike, but the totals and daily chart do not establish why the change happened. I would compare the affected pages and the same queries across relevant dates, then inspect the roster page’s answer before deciding whether it needs rewriting.

This is a worked recommendation for this data. Compare its evidence and its next check with yours; if you'd check something else first, say what it would settle.

To get the same views for your own site in Search Console, open Performance, then Search results. Set the two date ranges, then use the Pages and Queries tabs, and add a Page filter to see one page’s searches. For more on reading these reports, start with Search Console as a visibility dashboard.

Next lesson: is this really a content gap?

Ready to build a whole page? Explore the Moat Map course (Free during early access).

Arrow keys move. Enter opens. Esc closes.

Ask Bella

Ask Bella Hayden's corgi, who answers from this site and cites every fact.

BELLA

WOOF. I'm Bella, Hayden's corgi. He's my human. Ask me about him; every answer cites its source.

Reading this page? The top button is my short version of it.

How it works: the answers are written ahead from this site's pages, and anything else gets a search of the site that shows you its exact words. Every claim has a numbered source you can tap. Nothing is generated while you wait, nothing is made up, and nothing you type leaves your browser. Every answer, in plain HTML

Top